Thanks for all the advice. An update on the situation. I got the package back saying the buyer was "no longer a resident." I messaged him telling him about the returned package and he informed me that he was in the process of moving, but his former apartment complex was supposed to be holding his mail. He still wanted the tie so I re-shipped the tie to his new address and it's supposed to be delivered on Monday.
6/26/16 at 12:27pm