I totally agree. I wanted to try it out and see what I thought about it. I think either the boots need to be changed or the pants. I usually wear jeans and chinos but my wool trousers were getting lonely in the closet.
It's all preference but I think Roger nailed it. It's about what fits you. I love the F last and 82 from E.G. however none of them work but the P2 and 202 work great which in my opinion are all great looking for dress or casual pieces. I'm wearing my new P2 boots with dress trousers today and with chinos yesterday. I'll post a picture of them when I get out of traffic.