I ordered 6 suits and a dozen shirts from Astor & Black in Chicago.
The rep was a very friendly, extremely nice guy.
Suits - When I received my suits, I've never had a "custom" suit fit so terribly that there tailor AND my own tailor said it would be impossible to make these even come close to fitting.
Shirts - fit was fine, nothing great, nothing terrible.
Suits - I had ordered only Scabal fabric and these suits were the worst quality...