Personally not a big fan of the first two recs, but did like some of the ones from Mater. More then what makes sense to spend right spend right now.
I'm considering the Baba. Found a local guy on Craigslist willing to sell some slightly used ones for a steal, but they are bleached oak. Wouldn't be my first choice in finish to go with my decor.
Ha! I didn't remember the Baba being the same chair here: