First off I personally love my full zip fish even more than my stark. I have last years fisherman and it fits TTS, although it doesn't have as much stretch as the stark. Like all SNS it fits slim through the body and arms.
I'm a little late to the MacAlister's convo, but i've owned a oiled leather pair for 2-3 years now and have never had a quality problem. While I haven't sloshed through snow or rain the construction seems to be holding up and the leather with a initial rub of mink oil has developed a nice little patina.
My expectations in buying JCrew branded footwear is not quality so therefore I do not care about the origin. The only reason I initially bought them was because I found...
Sites with SNS sales:
20% off with code BLACK20
25% off all orders. No code needed.
Free Shipping with COLORFUL
11/23 only 30% off: BLACKFRIDAY2012 EDIT: seems this code has already expired.