I have both and they're excellent. I've heard that the Oogy "isn't as good as it was" too but that's meaningless if you haven't actually tried the previous batch. It's still really, really good. It mellows with age, though (as I think most peated whiskies do). I'm waiting to try the Ardbeg Corryvreckan. Apparently it's just as good as the Oogy and a bit stronger. That all said, I'm getting happier and happier with Talisker.
8/8/15 at 9:54am