Thanks again for your responses guys.
Ok so here is the final tally on what's available based on your very helpful suggestions:
Old Scout 6
Old Scout 10
Old Scout Store Private Bottling
Four Roses Single Barrel, Barrel Strength
They also suggested:
Black Maple Hill Rye
Michter's 10 year Rye
I've had the Black Maple Hill Bourbon but never the rye so I'd love some help on that.
Right now I'm leaning towards the FR and the Old Scout Private Store Bottling.