It's probably a size short, yeah. I wouldn't say "super short," though.It's a 48 with 50 lengths, and I probably should have gotten a 50 with 52 lengths. I'm a bit lanky and sometimes hard to size; should have known TOJ ran a bit slim, though.
The ones from Acrimony and Forward are 100% cotton, though. Wasn't the older versions a wool/silk blend or something a bit more interesting? $200+ for a cotton sweatshirt is a bit much imo, even for Geller.