I don't have any experience with any of the brands you mentioned. If I were to choose, I'll be picking from either Charles Tyrwhitt or TM Lewin as far as fit goes. The only thing I don't like with TM Lewin is the shorter collar. I like my shirt collars to be flushed in my jacket's lapels as well. Brooks Brothers' slim fit still runs full.
It's one jacket only so it could be just that. Of course, it is disappointing not to get the quality you expected (thinner leather, very grainy leather, etc.) especially when compared to the other jackets posted here that have better leather quality.