I personally think they're both too short to be useful. The ways I like to tie my scarf all seem to require a minimum of about 72" length to work.If that's not an issue for you, I do like Johnstons of Elgin's cashmere scarves.
Seconded. The fit is very close and needs only minor adjustment; there's no reason to resort to the sartorial elephant's graveyard of pleats.(Preparing to endure a bombardment of pocketwatches, spats with kilties, Rogaine cans and fedoras from the pro-pleat lobby. Come at me bros.)