I'm going to have to bite the bullet and give it a try. Will go for square shoulder. PC advised against it because it raises the armpits which are already snug. I have no choice cant deal with the pulling on that top button. Very uncomfortable. Thanks guys!
I have the same issue, where the 2nd button is tight across the upper chest. I think this is contributing to the problems. In my case, we were never able to resolve it. Changing slopes, widths, yokes, etc. I would also warn on making any adjustments on the smaller side, because shirts can arrive .25-.5 bigger/smaller.
I'm currently using sloping shoulder, because it adds room to the tiny armholes. Perhaps I can try without it. PC lacks the ability to customize armholes I think I'm out of luck. I've enlarged the chest/arms/yoke/beck back all larger than I'd like and still have problems.
Is it 'normal' to get pull lines on the second button when the top button is undone? [because the top button isn't anchoring everything together]. It seems that no matter how large i make the chest, or yoke it still happens. I'm wondering id anyone had similar issue:
Here is an example: http://i.imgur.com/NeHXUPtt.jpg
Here is a picture that demonstrates the difference between the Colorodo BD and the President spread and how they cover the middle of the neck.
So I'm wondering if I should shorten the Colorodo collar, or lower the button to get some breathing air?
Here's a pic of the neck back which is probably not necessary since the collar roll is there regardless.