My foot measurements are same as yours. I take an 8.5/9D in an 888 side gusset and a monkstrap that's snug,but fits. My guess is an E fitting in the same size would be fine for a lace-up. The width of your foot requires you to go a 1/2...
Italian polish might make a black shoe stand out among other shoes,but some have mentioned the polish does not last over time.
A cap toe would counter the sleek 3 eyelet blucher look. If you choose a cap toe it would look better on an...