Both are great! MrDV has a good point, though I would also wear the Aberdeen with a nice pair of chinos. Heck, I'd probably wear Aberdeen with dark selvedge too (which is the only kind of jeans I wear...), but if I planned to mainly wear them with jeans I'd go for the Barrie.Does one last fit better than the other?
It's funny how preferences change. I used to think that the split seem on the Aberdeen NST boots were too long, and then I finally wore my pair and fell in love. Extremely comfortable on my feet, too. Also saw a pair of WT boots on Aberdeen on AoC's Instagramaccount and they looked great.But you have a good point, I love Plaza-lasted boots too, don't think you can go wrong with any of those two lasts.