Honestly, if they fit well I would recommend giving them a few more chances since you're already taking a loss. They might grow on you. If you were my size, I wouldn't recommend this and would purchase immediately.
Got my derbies today. Left shoe has the same issue with lopsided eyelets. Right shoe is fine. The shoes are pretty damn awesome otherwise, so not sure I'll pursue any correction as the idea of waiting longer to wear them is unappealing. Must say its kinda disappointing considering the price point...maybe some growing pains with a relatively new model? Who knows.