I purchased the last LBM grey twill overcoat. It's pretty nice ...someone please buy the last houndstooth before I have a weak moment (ie weekend drink + internet). I'm usually 42R/52 and the 54 is perfect.
I couldn't decide between cigar and cognac either, so I just went with both. The shade of the cognac in the IG side shot looked a little less red than the store shots (at least on my phone), so that convinced me.
My current EP suede trainers crease right around the first lace, which should keep a nice toe cap on the shell version. With the low toe box and thinner shell, I'm hoping it doesn't amputate my toes at the crease.