Because if you tally all your posts in this thread it amounts to 3 pages of material. That means over the course of the last year I've had to click the "next" page button 3 times more than were necessary.
I could be wrong, but that first one doesn't look like oiled horse. The ones I've seen are extremely smooth and grain free. But I don't think you can go wrong with either choice. My preference was for the oiled horse.