Finishing (vague word) will be better on the Galway. Leathers probably better with EG as well, especially outsole (if you're going leather sole). Construction is inherently superior with Bonafe. I'd suggest going with the Galway, since that's what you originally wanted, it's cheaper than it ever will be now with USD strong, and that boot will always be in the back of your mind. It is the definitive country boot.