Hello, I'm no shoe expert so take what I say with a grain of salt. I had a problem like this before and it was because my left foot was slightly smaller than my right and the shoes were a tiny bit too long. What fixed the problem for me was sizing down one size lengthwise and getting a wider size. If anything, maybe you can try to get refitted if you are unsatisfied? Nordstrom has an excellent return policy. Anyway, good luck with everything.