What's your height and weight? More importantly, honestly assess the physical shape you're in. More stocky and/or shorter men look better in shorter, wider lasts with more traditional toe shapes. Pretty much all AE fall into this...
celeste_pisa - sent you a PM. Measurements on the shoes?
chobochobo - I own a bunch of To Boot shoes, I'm a 9 in that. But every other dress shoe I wear is a 9.5. Generally my shoes are 12 - 12.25" long. Do you know how the...