ShootThePier thanks for the kind words, I'm glad I swayed you into getting an Appaloosa!
I just ordered the midnight version last night, as the original lot A has become one of my favorite shirts that I own.
And I think I will end up going for the 12 as per your recommendations, and if they end up being a little big I can always buy some insoles.
I have a little bit of toe room at the end of my foot on my 11.5 Indy boots, but the width and heel feel very nice. Most...