You can't see the fit on the second guy's outfit...first guy's fit is alright. What are we voting on here? Which outfit is the most visually appealing?...second guy's by a mile. Which one would I wear?...neither.
Yeah. Taking in otr shirts is only a good idea when you're in a pinch or you see a pattern that you just have to have. You just end up spending more for a shirt that isn't quite right. For the price of a RL, couldn't you just buy a mtm? That's probably what I'd do.
I think that the suit supply one is gone. It shouldn't be too tough to find one. I'm not sure what your price range is, but on the low end of cost, you may be able to find something interesting in Jos. A. Bank or The Men's Wearhouse.