Yoyo's CPs do look heavily worn, but he others following from the others which are also ruined are not trashed.
I've had 2 pairs which tore along the sole stitch line but they were the Tournament Suede Lows.
Never had any issues with the lined models, so am surprised as I believed the above pairs to be lined/stronger.
That said, mine tore right through at the ball on both, and we're unlined. These are treating in other places.