You should ask in the Scent of the Day thread. There are a lot of knowledgeable guys there.(e.g. @Baron ) I like all those elements except smoke and vanilla. For a light leather, I like Helmut Lang Cuiron. Le Labo Vetiver 46 is sorta woody/herbal with some smoke. But there are tons of other options. TF stuff is too potent for me but he's got some like that. You might also like some of the CdG Incense series.