How wide are your feet? Do you usually wear a US E width?
Originally Posted by josepidal
I would go for the Mackay, because I personally think I'd rather have a casual loafer in a more casual color than dark brown.
The Mackay and Barksdale have incredibly different fits, though. When I bought my first Mackays at the Mansion, the salesman also made me try the Barksdales. He told me he couldn't sell me any loafers because they were so narrow...