Hm, I don't think that would change what I said.
If the 1000s are a look that works for you, then try and emulate that with the White's.
Do you shine your boots regularly, or just periodically apply protection?
That might affect which leather you choose, since some take a shine better than others.
An oil tan type of leather may prove more durable for a wearer who misses the occasional clean-up or buff, since the protection is manufactured in.