You might be able to score a Dalton 2nd in your size starting tomorrow. The Rediscover America 2nds sale price is $199. A great deal on a fantastic boot. I have them in bourbon and love them. I'd stay away from the Fifth Street as a casual shoe because it is not a blucher. Bluchers tend to be better for jeans or chinos.
I realize this is not an AE-specific post, but given we have a good number of Horween fans in this thread, thought I'd pass along that Huckberry carries some casual wallets and watch bands made from Horween leather. Not shell cordovan, but still Horween quality.