I won these AE shell loafers in size 9D. I'm a 9d on the brannock device but these fit me slighty long. I'm getting heel slippage. I can make them work with some heel thingys and/or thicker sox, but I'm not gonna do that. If you are a 9.5D they should work. Yours for what I paid for them: $112.
Very good to excellent condition. Minimal if any foot imprint. Color is darker brown with hints of cherry. Not old enough to have developed patina.