Tricker's quality is first rate.
The Comipel quality kind of varies. I'd say it ranges from okay to "seems about the same Horween". My oldest pair of Comipel felt thin. It's held up okay but it doesn't have that same bulletproof feel of the Horween shell.
Most of it seems pretty good though. Certainly good enough for me. One big advantage of Comipel is the wide range of colors. I've got pairs in orange, green, red, and now navy in addition to the various...