Number 2, man. Why don't you like metal buttons? Number 1 - not liking it. Number 3 is impressive but arms are really really tight and cut very high. If I was gonna get it I would have to size my size 3 in Devoa to 4 and still not sure how it would look on me. But you don't seem to have massive arms so could work fine for you. I like your PH jacket a lot.