Brand new brown Delrays.
I know they're not the fanciest shoes in the world, but Delrays are my workhorse (I have them in Chili, and I had a real old pair in brown). They're fantastic every day shoes, especially with a pair of chinos or cotton pants. I don't know why SF seems to be lukewarm at best when it comes to them/their split toe, but they're some of the most versatile (and best looking) shoes AE makes. And they're made on the best last there is.