Um ... I think EVERY retailer asks the buyer to send a photo if there is something wrong with the order. How else is your complaint even vaguely verifiable?! Gilt asked the same of me when I bought a CK Collection shirt advertised as "Made in Italy", which turned out to be "Made in Tunisia" or something.
Just wore my Everlane t-shirts for the first time. Fit was perfect, material was great, and tagless is a definite plus.
FYI I ordered an XS. I'm 5 '8, around 130 lbs, chest is 35ish.
Please make more colours! A few more shades of blue/red/grey would be nice.
I don't know of any other mid level brand that makes a grand total of only 10 (or whatever it is) different items. One of the pros of a small super focussed company like Everlane should be consistency. Not that I'm complaining. I havent yet had a chance to try out their t-shirts which I've ordered so as of now I have no view on whether they are or are not consistent.