Overnighted some J Crew 405 Indy's to hopefully nail my sizing. Preordered a size 12 for now, but will let you know by Sunday night for sure Mike.
Thanks everyone for your input. Stoked to finally get some quality Aldens.
11.5 in converse chuckies that are a little tight.
12 in OSB Shell Trench Boots that are a little tight as well and have never worn them.
I was thinking of maybe ordering the Indy's from J.Crew in size 12 just to try them out and return?