I have EG loafers on a couple different lasts. I get them in D with (EGs slightly narrow width) and the fit, at least for my foot, is terrific. An EG E width loafer is doable but I prefer D. Most C&Js, in D width, are subject to MTO prices. None of my EG loafers are MTO. C&J loafers in E width are unwearable for me - heel comes out of the shoe.The black Piccadilly is a classic. The 184 last has a nice shape and fit.As an aside, G&Gs KN14 last is a sublime fitting loafer last.